Carolyn P. Boyd (1944-2015): Historian of modern Spain; AHA member
James Boyden, Andrew H. Lee, and Timothy Tackett, September 2016
Historian of modern Spain; AHA member
Carolyn P. Boyd, a world-renowned scholar of modern Spain, died at her home in Irvine, California, on July 19, 2015, after a long bout with cancer. She was 71. Born in La Jolla, California, she was raised in Idaho and received her undergraduate education at Stanford University and her doctorate at the University of Washington. Widely recognized for her reinterpretation of the origins of the Spanish Civil War, she was also highly acclaimed for signal insights into the course and meanings of Spanish national history and identity. She enjoyed a long and distinguished career as a professor of history and a respected administrator, first at the University of Texas at Austin and then at the University of California, Irvine.
As a historian of modern Spain, Boyd played a major role in the dramatic reorientation of the field in the decades after the death of Francisco Franco in 1975. Characterized by exceptionally broad reading, painstaking archival research, and keen analytical skills, Boyd’s work meticulously set about to rethink many of the central problems of modern Spanish history, notably the role of the military in politics and the reasons for the troubled trajectory of Spain’s nation formation. Her first book, Praetorian Politics in Liberal Spain (Univ. of North Carolina Press, 1979), demolished the long-held notion that it was endemic and institutionally irreconcilable antagonisms between civilian politicians and meddling officers that destabilized parliamentary government and ultimately led to civil war. Instead, she demonstrated that the governing political parties of the 19th and 20th centuries themselves “created the praetorian army that later destroyed them.”
In another pathbreaking work, Historia Patria: Politics, History, and National Identity in Spain, 1875–1975 (Princeton Univ. Press, 1997), Boyd deeply probed the study and teaching of history in modern Spain, placing them in social and political context. She argued persuasively that Spaniards failed to reach a consensus on the national past. This simultaneously reflected and perpetuated weak political institutions and regional identities (especially among the Catalans and Basques), and hindered the development of an overarching national identity. Historia Patria won recognition far beyond the confines of Spanish history, and remains a landmark study in the broader history of European education and culture. That her first two books were each rapidly translated into Spanish, a rare honor for the work of an American historian, further indicates their considerable significance.
Boyd brought to her research and writing a profoundly sympathetic appreciation of Spanish culture, yet she was impatient with mythmaking, whether it originated on the right or on the left of the political spectrum. In well-worn stereotypes about Spanish national character she saw interesting cultural significance but little interpretive value. The modern history of Spain, Boyd believed, was distinctive but not deviant, and her scholarship was central to an emerging consensus that would situate developments in the Iberian Peninsula within the broader contexts of European and Western history. While her sensibilities and insights often verged on the poetic—few Spanish historians have been more profoundly affected by art and literature—her writing was always clear and concise, free of mystification, obfuscation, or jargon. Indeed, Carolyn Boyd embodied the virtues most prized by historians: persistence, discipline, linguistic facility, rigorous analysis, and clarity and precision of expression.
Considering that she entered the field when there were relatively few English-speaking scholars and even fewer women working on modern Spain, Boyd’s accomplishments rise to a still more impressive level. In Spain itself, historians had been practically unable to examine the nation’s recent past because of the constraints imposed by the Francoist regime and its ideology. The education of those coming of age during the dictatorship consisted of a one-sided indoctrination in national history as seen by the victors of the Civil War. As a young woman in Franco’s Spain, pursuing research on the traditionally masculine topic of the military, Boyd played a pioneering role in the rediscovery of the Spanish past. Following Franco’s demise, she was a key figure in the expansion of scholarly cooperation between Spaniards and foreign historians.
In her later work, Boyd focused on the complex issue of historical memory and commemoration in contemporary Spain, on how the past is perceived and how history is imagined or manipulated. Here too her work, in the form of a series of important articles, stood at the cutting edge of current historical research. Most recently, she was chosen as one of only two North American contributors to the massive history of Spain (Historia de España) published in Madrid in 2013. She served as coauthor for the 12th and final volume in the series, which is devoted to “histories of Spain: visions of the past and the construction of identity” (Las historias de España: Visiones del pasado y construcción de identidad), published by Marcial Pons and largely inspired by her own seminal book, Historia Patria.
Testimonies about her life have invariably noted that she was universally liked and an exemplary teacher, mentor, colleague, friend, and administrator, always generous with her time, knowledge, wisdom, and counsel. She is survived by her husband, Frank D. Bean, of Irvine, California; her brother, Paul M. Boyd, of Boise, Idaho; her sons, Peter J. Bean and Michael F. Bean, of Austin, Texas, and New York City, respectively; her stepchildren, Alan M. Bean and Deborah Copas, of Austin; and her two step-grandchildren. Memorial donations may be made to the Orange County Women’s Chorus, of which she was a valued and enthusiastic member (www.ocwomenschorus.org/support-us).
James Boyden, Tulane University
Andrew H. Lee, New York University
University of California, Irvine
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Attribution must provide author name, article title, Perspectives on History, date of publication, and a link to this page. This license applies only to the article, not to text or images used here by permission.