Publication Date

November 14, 2013

In an effort to highlight the diverse range of scholarship at the upcoming annual meeting, we’re highlighting different sessions here on the blog each week.

History-WarsTwo decades ago vehement disputes were raging in our profession over what was variously termed “postmodernism,” “post-structuralism,” “the linguistic turn,” or even more generally “cultural history.” At the time, the mere mention of Michel Foucault was enough to make many a conference panel or department meeting descend into name-calling. Although the occasional voice is sometimes still raised In Defense of History (the title of Richard Evans’s embattled 1997 volume), that controversy has subsided, and an open-minded eclecticism seems to characterize today’s historical practice. The theme of this conference offers an excellent opportunity to take stock and look back at the stories, meaning, and legacy of the fraught but productive intellectual strife of the 1990s for our discipline. The five panelists will do so by addressing some of the following themes: what contextual, historical, and/or sociological factors account for the debates that erupted in the 1990s? What was really at stake behind the rhetoric? What was their own role in, or experience of, that time? Are there comparable controversies today over method and theory, and if not why not? Is the apparent decline of methodological controversy a gain or a loss? In sum, what was the meaning of the “postmodernism crisis” in the American historical profession, and what is its legacy?

The five panelists are all distinguished historians who have either contributed to or written about the methodological debates of the 1990s: Kessler-Harris as a feminist historian with a record of engagement in the public sphere; Oakes as a skeptical observer/participant in the debates; Rodgers as the author of a prize-winning intellectual history, The age of Fracture, which covers this period;  Sewell and Spiegel as the authors of essays and books about historical and social scientific theory.

AHA Session 102

Friday, January 3, 2014: 2:30 PM-4:30 PM

Marriott Ballroom, Salon 1 (Marriott Wardman Park)

Chair: Sarah C. Maza, Northwestern University


Alice Kessler-Harris, Columbia University

James Oakes, City University of New York, Graduate Center

Daniel T. Rodgers, Princeton University

William H. Sewell, University of Chicago

Gabrielle M. Spiegel, Johns Hopkins University

This post first appeared on AHA Today.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License. Attribution must provide author name, article title, Perspectives on History, date of publication, and a link to this page. This license applies only to the article, not to text or images used here by permission.